• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Rose Litigation Lawyers

Contact us today
Brisbane: (07) 3211 2922
Gold Coast: (07) 5574 0011
  • Expertise
    • Litigation
      • Body Corporate Disputes
      • Class Actions & Representative Proceedings
      • Defamation Lawyers Brisbane & Gold Coast
      • Professional Negligence
      • Trusts Disputes
      • Will Dispute Lawyers
    • Insolvency, Bankruptcy & Debt Recovery
      • Bankruptcy
      • Corporate Insolvency Lawyers Brisbane, Gold Coast
      • Debt Recovery
      • Guarantees
      • PPSA
      • Restructuring
      • Securities
      • Security Enforcement
    • Building, Construction & Infrastructure
      • Adjudication
      • Contract Preparation & Risk Management
      • Dispute Resolution
      • Subcontractors’ Charges & Security of Payment
      • Supply & Trading Terms
    • Business Disputes
      • Consumer Protection & Trade Practices Disputes
      • Contract Disputes
      • Corporate Advisory & Crisis Management
      • Employment Disputes
      • Franchising Disputes
      • Insurance Disputes
      • Intellectual Property Disputes
      • Shareholder Dispute Lawyer Brisbane & Gold Coast
      • Company Director Disputes
    • Regulatory & Government
        • Administrative Appeals
        • ASIC Investigations
        • Government
        • Regulatory Investigations & Licencing
        • Taxation Disputes
    • Property Disputes
      • Commercial Lease & Retail Shop Lease Disputes
      • Conveyancing, Planning & Environment Disputes
  • Team
  • About Us
    • Why Choose Us
    • What our clients say
    • Our Community Stem
    • Join Our Team
    • Current Opportunities
  • Knowledge Centre
  • Contact Us
Obligation Free consultation

Does your Body Corporate Act Reasonably?

Request an obligation free consultation

Fill out the form below and outline your concerns. We’ll get back to you to organise your consultation.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Does your Body Corporate Act Reasonably?

Property Disputes

15 Dec 2016

The High Court of Australia was recently asked to consider the age old question of ‘what would a reasonable Body Corporate do?’ The matter of Ainsworth v Albrecht related to a motion proposed by a lot owner to renovate two existing decks at his property at Viridian Noosa Residences, by joining them to create one larger space. This would have required granting the owner exclusive use of the common property airspace between the two existing decks, which under the relevant legislation (the BCCMA) required approval without dissent by special resolution. The owner’s motion was defeated and he applied for dispute resolution under the BCCMA, alleging that opposition by members to the proposal was unreasonable.

After a lengthy progression through the Adjudicator’s office and the higher Queensland Courts, the matter came before the High Court, where the Court had to determine if it was incumbent on members of a body corporate scheme to balance the competing interests of other lot owners when casting their vote, as well as what constitutes ‘unreasonable opposition’ to a motion put before them.

Overturning the finding of the Court of Appeal, the High Court held as a matter of law, that there is no requirement on individual Body Corporate members to balance the competing interests of another lot owner. The Court determined that the standard of reasonableness is objective, and “A proposal could not, on any rational view, adversely affect the material enjoyment of an opponent’s property rights” and opposition would be unreasonable if “it is prompted by spite, or ill-will, or a desire of attention, given the circumstances of the particular case.”

In this instance, the dissenting lot owners held the opinion – supported by independent expert evidence – that the proposed alterations would affect their privacy; impinge on the original architectural intent of the scheme; leave them without remedy for the loss of their enjoyment of the effected common property; and leave open the possibility of a number of future similar works being carried out. The Court therefore held, “The proposal in question was apt to create a reasonable apprehension that it would affect adversely the property rights of opponents of the proposal and the enjoyment of those rights. In these circumstances, opposition of the lot owners who dissented from the proposal could not be said to be unreasonable”. The Court awarded costs against the applicant lot owner.

The case of Ainsworth v Albrecht provides a clear direction to Body Corporate members, that when exercising their individual voting rights on matters of special resolution, they are under no obligation to consider the property interests of the party proposing the motion. For parties putting forward a motion, a helpful tip from the case is that the offer of compensation for effected property rights may assist in demonstrating unreasonableness of opposition to that motion. This is especially so if it assists in avoiding future lengthy, expensive court proceedings.

Rose Litigation Lawyers are specialist litigation lawyers with Body Corporate division. We advise lot owners, body corporates and body corporate managers, and are here to assist you with any issues you may have. Please contact Partner, Melissa Inglis if you have a body corporate dispute or require advice on your legal position in relation to a body corporate matter.

SHARE:

Primary Sidebar

Areas of Practice

  • Business Services
  • Sales & Marketing
  • Litigation
  • Insolvency, Bankruptcy & Debt Recovery
  • Building, Construction & Infrastructure
  • Business Disputes
  • Regulatory & Government
  • Property Disputes
Rose Litigation Lawyers

Specialists In

  • Litigation
  • Insolvency, Bankruptcy & Debt Recovery
  • Building & Construction Lawyers Brisbane, Gold Coast
  • Business Disputes
  • Regulatory & Government
  • Property Disputes

Useful Links

  • Why Choose Us?
  • Our Team
  • Knowledge Centre
  • Contact Us

Brisbane

(07) 3211 2922
[email protected]
Level 16
324 Queen Street
Brisbane QLD 4000

Gold Coast

(07) 5574 0011
[email protected]
Level 9, Corporate Centre One
2 Corporate Court
Bundall QLD 4217

Proud member of:

Queensland Law Society logo Law Council of Australia logo CCF Logo 3 ALPMA Logo 4 Queensland Young Lawyers Logo 3 WIRQ Logo

Rose Litigation Lawyers © 2025 Liability Limited by a scheme under professional standards legislation
  • Sitemap
Website by